The Washington Post's political columnist Ruth Marcus is the author of a disappointing piece on Caroline Kennedy's possible assumption of Hillary Clinton's senate seat. Marcus is torn, she writes, between her head, which thinks Caroline Kennedy shouldn't become senator from New York, and her heart, which thinks that it would be a fitting place for an American political princess.
Her reasons against Kennedy? It's "creepy" when kids go into the same fields as their parents. In addition, on the ideological level, political dynasties are anti-meritocratic, while practically, they haven't had good returns.
However, countering these arguments, Marcus cites such political luminaries as Jesse Ventura, Arnold, and Sonny Bono, who also skipped up to the top levels of politics without paying their dues. She also notes that Kennedy has impressive experience outside the political realm as a Constitutional scholar (Kennedy has written a book on the subject) and proponent of educational reform.
Finally, though, what appears to carry the day is the soap-opera nature of Kennedy's ascension:
There are any number of intriguing subplots at work here. Her uncle's illness, and the "dream will never die" emotion of having Caroline in place to carry on his work. The don't-mess-with-my-family payback dynamic of putting in for the job to shove aside Andrew Cuomo, her cousin Kerry's former husband
and, of course, the ideological significance behind the decision:
Then, deciding that Obama is the first candidate with the inspirational appeal of her father, she chooses to abandon her previous, above-it-all detachment from the hurly-burly of politics.
I think Caroline Kennedy would probably be a very good Senator, but I don't actually know too much about the woman besides the pedigree. What I do know is that if the parties were reversed, I would be disgusted at the idea of Doro Bush finishing someone's Senate term simply because she is from a multigenerational political family.
We are about to escape from what was the most overtly corrupt, unabashedly cronyistic administration in the last 50 years. The Democrats are now presented with the opportunity to show people how it is done the right way. No matter how nice it feels, and how special we all know she is, Caroline Kennedy hasn't earned the right to be the senator from New York, even as a fill-in. If she gets the position, it's a black mark against the Dems, and a big sign that we are still looking at politics as usual.
Recent Comments